Welcome Guest! You have made 44 posts!

Join Our Discord! : Here After high demand from everyone, we've finally opened a Discord Chat Server for the site!
We are an AU Naruto Roleplay Forum!

    To End the Debate once and for all

    Masaru
    Masaru

    Posts : 228
    Join date : 2020-02-19

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Masaru Fri Jul 17, 2020 3:42 pm

    This is a simple vote, however to keep thing proper this is how it will work. Every Player gets 1 vote, not every character, If you vote on multiple accounts All of your votes will be Invalid.

    Immunity to B-Rank and lower has been approved and how it works is you can only hold immunity to a single Element/whatever. It takes 1 of the 3 attunement slots a character is allowed at one time, and you can't switch in the middle of a thread because of it.

    A 2 Tier Reduction to damage from a source was also approved, takes an attunement slot and is an enchantment with 45 chargers.

    This is already been established and is not in question, the discussion is over however since Admins can't agree i have decided that the vote will come to the site.

    So I ask you,
    Should these things be allowed to stack, and grant full immunity to a Single source such as Raiton based attacks, etc?

    To ensure that no one votes twice and their stance on the matter is counted, you will be required to make a post here stating one of the following.

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"

    Or

    "Yes, These should be allowed to Stack!"

    This vote will conclude in Exactly 48hrs from the time posted to give everyone on site a chance to vote, at which time the majority will rule and we will move forward with this.


    _________________
    Character Update: Link
    Known Techniques: Link
    Yuki Kaida
    Yuki Kaida
    Jounin

    Posts : 136
    Join date : 2017-11-13

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Yuki Kaida Fri Jul 17, 2020 3:47 pm

    No, these should not be allowed to Stack, stacking would be absolutely stupid and make them immune to everything in existence.


    _________________
    Signature:
    Character Name: Yuki Kaida
    Spendable Experience: 0
    Total Experience: 2,850/3,500
    Renown: 3,000
    Ryo: 500,000
    Stats:

    • Strength: D
    • Constitution: C
    • Stamina: B
    • Speed: B
    • Coordination: B
    • Intelligence: B
    • Perception: C


    Link to Character Updates:
    Link to Character Application: [url=https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t4339-yuki-kaida-b-rank-wanderer#33726

    Link to Known Techniques:
    Uchiha Akihiro
    Uchiha Akihiro
    Anbu

    Posts : 869
    Join date : 2018-08-06
    Age : 24

    Character File
    Skills & Elements:
    Class: X
    Ryo: a looot

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Uchiha Akihiro Fri Jul 17, 2020 3:49 pm

    Rolling Eyes

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"


    _________________
    AriDokuma
    AriDokuma

    Village : N/A
    Posts : 137
    Join date : 2020-06-06

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by AriDokuma Fri Jul 17, 2020 3:52 pm

    I don't mind something like this stacking, however from an outside perspective I think it'll be easier to simply put down that resistances of the same element shouldn't stack. This doesn't necessarily mean you can't have multiple resistances, but I believe having the option to either not be damaged up to a certain rank in a certain element or just take up a two tier damage reduction from said element would suffice in terms of balancing.


    _________________
    Character Name: Ari Dokuma
    Spendable Experience: 0
    Total Experience: 2030
    Renown: 0
    Ryo: 171,892
    Stats:

    • Strength: C
    • Constitution: C
    • Stamina: C+
    • Speed: B
    • Coordination: B
    • Intelligence: B
    • Perception: B

    Limit Break Points:

    • Physical:
    • Technique:
    • Destiny:

    Link to Character Updates: https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t3685-dokuma-s-updates?nid=14#28855
    Link to Character Application: https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t3683-ari-dokuma
    Link to Known Techniques:
    Kimiko
    Kimiko

    Posts : 129
    Join date : 2019-08-23

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kimiko Fri Jul 17, 2020 3:54 pm

    "Yes, These should be allowed to Stack!"
    It takes up 2 of the 3 attunement slots, and there are plenty of ways to nullify that advantage by damaging the items, using fuuin, using other jutsu, etc etc.


    _________________
    Spoiler:
    Character Name: Kimiko Uchiha
    Spendable Experience: 755
    Total Experience: 7055
    Renown: 3000
    Ryo: 120,750
    Stats:

    • Strength: C
    • Constitution: B
    • Stamina: B+
    • Speed: B
    • Coordination: A
    • Intelligence: A
    • Perception: B

    Limit Break Points:

    • Physical:
    • Technique:
    • Destiny: 3

    Link to Character Updates: https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t2426-kimiko-s-updates#19534
    Link to Character Application:
    Link to Known Techniques:
    Kitsuki Kurahasa
    Kitsuki Kurahasa
    Genin

    Posts : 818
    Join date : 2017-09-14

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kitsuki Kurahasa Fri Jul 17, 2020 4:02 pm

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"

    Why are we even having this debate? This is utterly absurd.



    _________________
    To End the Debate once and for all SYGNA

    Spoiler:
    Stats:
    Strength: S
    Constitution: S
    Stamina: A
    Speed: C
    Coordination: C
    Intelligence: D
    Perception: A


    Gear
    Quantum Meruit Armour [50/43]
    Amicus Curiae [20/20 Explosions]
    100 Broadhead Arrows [C-Grade Quality]
    Evanescence
    Kyoji
    Kyoji
    Mizukage

    Posts : 396
    Join date : 2018-05-23
    Age : 29

    Character File
    Skills & Elements: Suiton/ Ninjutsu, Kenjutsu, Taijutsu
    Class: A
    Ryo: Ya boy is ballin

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kyoji Fri Jul 17, 2020 4:08 pm

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"

    There's usually a Restricted or KKG behind total immunities.


    _________________
    Stats:
    Strength: B > S (EGF)
    Constitution: B > A (Kaguya)
    Stamina: A++ (Senju)
    Speed: B
    Coordination: B > S (EGF)
    Intelligence: D
    Perception: A
    Kuro
    Kuro
    Genin

    Village : Kumogakure
    Posts : 36
    Join date : 2020-06-24
    Age : 30

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kuro Fri Jul 17, 2020 4:58 pm

    Considering the sort of other defenses that bloodlines and whatever other skills the character may have in their repertoire can give them, this would be pretty broken if allowed.

    So, my vote will also be "No, they should not be allowed to stack".


    _________________
    Character Name: Kuro Chinoike
    Spendable Experience: 99
    Total Experience: 999
    Renown: 0
    Ryo: 0
    Stats:

    • Strength: D

    • Constitution: D

    • Stamina: D (Chakra Pool: 50/50 CP)

    • Speed: D (8 m/s)

    • Coordination: D (1 hand sign/s)
         
    • Intelligence: D
       
    • Perception: D


    Link to Character Updates: KURO'S UPDATES

    Link to Character Application: KURO CHINOIKE (COMPLETE)

    Link to Known Techniques: See updates link for more details

    • Universal Claim: All canon E-rank Academy jutsu

    • Five Free Starter Jutsu
    Akari Uchiha
    Akari Uchiha
    Genin

    Posts : 464
    Join date : 2018-08-27
    Age : 28

    Character File
    Skills & Elements:
    Class: A
    Ryo:

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Akari Uchiha Fri Jul 17, 2020 7:21 pm

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"

    This, right here.


    _________________
    Character Name: Akari Uchiha
    Spendable Experience: 145
    Total Experience:  4,925
    Renown: 2,500
    Ryo: 79,650
    Stats:

    • Strength: C
    • Constitution: C
    • Stamina: A+
    • Speed: A
    • Coordination: A
    • Intelligence: A
    • Perception: B


    Limit Break Points: We

    • Physical: Dont
    • Technique: Have
    • Destiny: These

    Link to Character Updates: Here
    Link to Character Application: No u
    Link to Known Techniques: Look in the above link buttercup
    Kara
    Kara
    Civilian

    Village : Kumogakure
    Posts : 324
    Join date : 2020-02-08
    Age : 29

    Character File
    Skills & Elements: Fuuton, Doton, Jiton, Chemisty, Iryojutsu, Master, Engineering, Investor, Weaponsmith, Armorsmith
    Class: A
    Ryo: More than I need, less than I'd like

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kara Fri Jul 17, 2020 9:42 pm

    "No, these should not be allowed to Stack!"


    _________________
    To End the Debate once and for all 4J1yre2

    Mistress Kara:
    Character Name: Kara Darhk
    Spendable Experience: 985
    Total Experience: 4985
    Renown: 24,400
    Ryo: 2,402,350
    Stats:

    • Strength: E
    • Constitution: C
    • Stamina: B+
    • Speed: D
    • Coordination: A
    • Intelligence: S
    • Perception: A

    Gear:


    • Sukuinote
    • Augmented Assassin’s Blade
    • 1 Sukuinote Vial Spinal Tap - inside Sukuinote
    • 2 each Sukuinote Vials - Spinal Tap and Stolid Rising
    • Stormsilver Particulate - inside Sukuinote
    • Medical Bag

    Ryuko
    Ryuko
    Raikage

    Posts : 1937
    Join date : 2017-09-29

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Ryuko Fri Jul 17, 2020 10:27 pm

    "Yes, These should be allowed to Stack!"

    It takes 2 attument slots and isn't even full complete immunity. Just because you're wearing a suit that nufflies attacks that hit it doesn't mean that you can be hit anywhere with those attacks with no effect.

    And it's just one element. Being partly immune to only one is far from being invincible. There's so many ways to attack or to to get around it that anyone thinking it'll make them untouchable will end up getting their butts kicked for their arrogance.

    How to beat someone tank your fire attacks with your fire attacks.




    Getting rid of it only makes the equipment system more shallow and takes away tactical options giving people less choices about how they want to approach a fight.

    For example Batman has an anti-ice suit for when he goes to fight Mr. Freeze but it won't do him any good if he gets jumped during general patrol when he doesn't have it equipped since it's not part of his standard load out. And it sure as heck won't help him if he ends up having to fight someone else like Firefly.

    TLDR - If you end up fighting someone you can't hurt with an element adapt.


    _________________
    Ryuko's Ninja Card

    Spoiler:

    Stats
    Strength: B
    Constitution: B
    Stamina: A++
    Speed: B
    Coordination: A
    Intelligence: A
    Perception: B

    On person
    Arch Angel Helm
    Arch Angel's Tiara
    Angelic Body suit
    Amulet of Kings
    Arch Angel's Rerebrace
    Arch Angels Cuirass
    Arch Angel's Faulds
    Angelic Base
    Angelic Gloves
    Bolt Ring
    Arch Angel's gauntlet's
    Tengādian (Heavenly Protector)
    Angelic Stockings
    Arch Angel's Boots
    Belt:
    - 4 Chakra Drones
    -Hakkin's Fang
    - Shikenri (Death Right)
    Belt holster 1:
    - Hakkin's Wrath A (Baton)
    - Windmill of Shadows
    Belt holster 2:
    - Hakkin's Wrath B (Baton)
    - Windmill of Shadows
    Hip Pouch 1
    - 1 Ninja wire (15 feet)
    -10 Kunai
    - 10 Shuriken
    - 100 Caltrops
    - 1 Med kit
    - Bag of Military Ration Pills (20)  
    Hip Pouch 2
    - 5 Kaminari Kunai
    - 10 Kaminari Shuriken
    - 20 Kaminari Senbons
    -10 Explosive Tags
    Back Holster:
    -Ersatz Sword of Kusanagi
    -Stardust Staff
    Mort
    Mort

    Posts : 284
    Join date : 2020-02-26
    Age : 23

    Character File
    Skills & Elements: None
    Class: E
    Ryo: 0

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Mort Sat Jul 18, 2020 11:09 am

    "Yes, These should be allowed to Stack!"
    But I have 2 caveats to that in my though process:
    1} There's nothing that I have found that says a KKG bloodline couldn't be made that increases their attunement slots a la 5e artificer, so if stacking becomes allowed it should be limited to 1 element or form of attack (pierce, blunt, slash, etc).
    2} If it's allowed it should only stick to non-elemental, primary/advanced elements, and forms of attack. Not Genjutsu, Fuinjutsu, Inton (Yin) nor Yoton (Yang).


    _________________
    The Mighty Warrior of Epicness:

    Character: Mōtimā Midori-Okō Kurama
    Class: A
    Renown: 1775
    Base Stats: 19/20 Raises
    Strength: D
    Constitution: C
    Stamina: B+ (210 CP)
    Speed: C
    Coordination: B
    Intelligence: S
    Perception: C

    Plot Tracker (And Other Links!): Link
    Updates: Link
    Uchiha Akihiro
    Uchiha Akihiro
    Anbu

    Posts : 869
    Join date : 2018-08-06
    Age : 24

    Character File
    Skills & Elements:
    Class: X
    Ryo: a looot

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Uchiha Akihiro Sun Jul 19, 2020 6:00 pm

    Timer ended.

    I count 7-3 in favour of not stacking. (I didn't quite get Ari's position)

    Can we please get this specified on the rules?


    _________________
    Kureji Toukei
    Kureji Toukei
    Genin

    Posts : 218
    Join date : 2018-07-27

    To End the Debate once and for all Empty Re: To End the Debate once and for all

    Post by Kureji Toukei Sun Jul 19, 2020 6:33 pm

    Despite the vote ending, thought I'd still add my two cents to this.

    I'm going to say no to the stacking.

    I'm not against the idea of immunity being a thing, but the idea that immunity can be bought with a small amount of ryo is ridiculous.

    This should be something along the lines of a KKG (i.e. a Hozuki having resistance if not outright immunity against Suiton) or a restricted having some form of immunity against an element or type of damage. These are the only scenarios I'd accept immunity to happen, and not something to be purchased with 50k/100k ryo.


    _________________
    Details:


    To End the Debate once and for all Cpk6Qcm

    Name: Kureji Toukei
    Stats:

    • Strength: C
    • Constitution: C
    • Stamina: A
    • Speed: C
    • Coordination: A
    • Intelligence: S
    • Perception: A

    Link to Updates: https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t2543-kureji-s-updates#20483
    Link to Application: https://gladiusnarutorp.forumotion.com/t2515-kureji-toukei

      Current date/time is Sat Jun 19, 2021 8:32 am